10 Best Restaurants in the Exumas You Need to Visit (2026 Guide)

By Banita Sadhra on 16th July, 2026

The Exumas may be famous for their sapphire-blue waters, secluded beaches, and swimming pigs, but they also boast a surprisingly diverse food scene. Across Great Exuma, Little Exuma, and the surrounding cays, you’ll find everything from laid-back beachfront cafés serving the day’s catch to elegant waterfront restaurants offering Caribbean-inspired fine dining. Fresh seafood is naturally at the heart of many menus, with local lobster, conch, grouper, snapper, and mahi-mahi appearing in dishes that celebrate the flavours of the Bahamas.

Whether you’re stopping for lunch after a day on the water or searching for the perfect sunset dinner overlooking Elizabeth Harbour, we’ve rounded up some of the best restaurants in the Exumas to add to your itinerary.

Santanna’s Bar & Grill (Little Exuma)

Perched above the turquoise waters of Little Exuma, Santanna’s Bar & Grill has become one of the islands’ most iconic dining destinations. The colourful open-air restaurant is loved for its laid-back atmosphere, panoramic ocean views, and fresh Bahamian seafood served just steps from the beach.

The menu features local favourites including grilled lobster, cracked conch, fresh grouper, conch fritters, and perfectly seasoned snapper. Guests often spend the afternoon swimming at nearby Coco Plum Beach before enjoying lunch on the terrace with a cold Kalik beer or tropical cocktail. With friendly service and spectacular scenery, Santanna’s perfectly captures the relaxed spirit of the Exumas.

Address: CCHQ+M9J, William’s Town, Bahamas

For more info visit: www.santannasbarandgrill.com

Chat ‘N’ Chill (Stocking Island)

No trip to the Exumas is complete without visiting Chat ‘N’ Chill. Located on Stocking Island, just across the harbour from George Town, this legendary beachfront restaurant has become a favourite stop for both boaters and visitors arriving by water taxi.

Known for its famous Sunday Pig Roast and fresh conch salad prepared right on the beach, Chat ‘N’ Chill offers an authentic Bahamian dining experience in a casual setting. Guests can enjoy grilled seafood, burgers, tropical drinks, and live music while relaxing with their feet in the sand. Stingrays often gather in the shallow waters nearby, adding to the unique island atmosphere.

Address: 1 Stocking Island | Volleyball Beach Stocking Island, Bahamas

For more info visit: www.chatnchill.com

23° North (Great Exuma)

Located at Grand Isle Resort & Residences overlooking Emerald Bay, 23° North offers one of the Exumas’ finest waterfront dining experiences. The elegant restaurant combines contemporary Caribbean flavours with fresh local ingredients, creating beautifully presented dishes in a relaxed yet sophisticated setting.

Guests can enjoy freshly caught seafood, premium steaks, handcrafted cocktails, and spectacular ocean views from the outdoor terrace. Whether visiting for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, the attentive service and stunning location make 23° North a popular choice for couples and travellers celebrating a special occasion.

Address: Grand Isle Resort And Spa, Rokers Point Settlement, Bahamas

For more info visit: www.23north.com

The Rusty Anchor (George Town)

Situated on the waterfront in George Town, The Rusty Anchor is well known for its relaxed marina setting and welcoming atmosphere. Overlooking Elizabeth Harbour, the restaurant provides the perfect place to enjoy lunch or dinner while watching boats come and go throughout the day.

The menu focuses on fresh seafood, grilled fish, lobster, conch, burgers, and Caribbean-inspired dishes prepared using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Guests particularly enjoy dining on the outdoor deck during sunset, when the harbour provides a beautiful backdrop for an evening meal.

Address: F6XR+22V, Michelson, Bahamas

For more info visit: www.therustyanchor.com

Shirley’s at the Fish Fry (George Town)

For an authentic taste of Bahamian home cooking, Shirley’s at the Fish Fry is a must-visit. Popular with both locals and visitors, this casual restaurant serves generous portions of traditional island favourites in a welcoming, family-friendly setting.

Menu highlights include cracked conch, fried snapper, grilled lobster, peas and rice, macaroni and cheese, and freshly prepared coleslaw. If you’re looking to experience genuine Bahamian hospitality and traditional recipes, Shirley’s remains one of the best local dining spots in the Exumas.

Address: G679+P3C, Queen’s Highway, Bahamas

For more info visit: www.shirleys.com

Big D’s Conch Spot (Little Exuma)

Located near the famous Tropic of Cancer Beach, Big D’s Conch Spot is one of Little Exuma’s most beloved roadside restaurants. The colourful beachfront location attracts visitors looking for fresh seafood, relaxed island vibes, and incredible ocean views.

Fresh conch salad is the signature dish, prepared to order using locally caught conch mixed with citrus, peppers, onions, and tomatoes. The menu also includes grilled lobster, fried fish, cracked conch, and refreshing tropical drinks, making it the perfect stop after exploring the island’s beautiful beaches.

Address: J3Q5+GP3, Steventon, Bahamas

For more info visit: www.bigdsconchspot.com

Blu on the Water (Great Exuma)

Located at Hideaways at Palm Bay, Blu on the Water combines contemporary island dining with stunning waterfront views. Its relaxed atmosphere and varied menu make it a popular choice for both hotel guests and visitors exploring Great Exuma.

The restaurant serves fresh seafood, pasta dishes, steaks, burgers, salads, and Bahamian specialities alongside an excellent selection of cocktails and wines. Regular live music and sunset dining create a lively atmosphere that perfectly complements its beachfront location.

Address: Rolletown, Bahamas

For more info visit: www.bluonthewater.com

Peace & Plenty Restaurant (George Town)

Located within the historic Peace & Plenty Resort, this long-established restaurant has welcomed visitors to the Exumas for generations. Overlooking Elizabeth Harbour, the restaurant combines traditional Bahamian hospitality with an elegant waterfront setting.

Guests can enjoy breakfast, lunch, and dinner featuring fresh seafood, grilled meats, pasta, and local specialities prepared with seasonal ingredients. The lively atmosphere, regular live entertainment, and beautiful harbour views make it one of George Town’s most popular dining destinations.

Address: George Town, Bahamas

For more info visit: www.peace&plentybeachclub.com

Tropic Breeze Beach Bar & Grill (Great Exuma)

Situated along Queen’s Highway, Tropic Breeze Beach Bar & Grill is a favourite among both locals and visitors looking for generous portions and a relaxed atmosphere. The restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating with easy access for travellers exploring Great Exuma.

The menu includes grilled lobster, cracked conch, fresh snapper, ribs, burgers, and a variety of Caribbean-inspired dishes. Friendly service, live entertainment on selected evenings, and a welcoming island atmosphere make it an excellent place to unwind after a day of sightseeing.

Address: CCJJ+XG2, William’s Town, Bahamas

For more info visit: www.tropicbreezebeachbar.com

Dining in the Exumas is about much more than simply enjoying a great meal—it’s about embracing the laid-back island lifestyle that makes this corner of the Bahamas so special. From beachfront seafood shacks and lively beach bars to elegant waterfront restaurants overlooking Elizabeth Harbour, every meal comes with its own unforgettable setting.

Whether you’re sampling freshly prepared conch salad on Stocking Island, enjoying grilled lobster in Little Exuma, or watching the sunset over the harbour in George Town, these restaurants showcase the flavours, hospitality, and natural beauty that make the Exumas such a remarkable destination. Wherever your adventures take you, you’ll never be far from an incredible meal.